Welcome to Papa Johns Pizza Sebring
At Papa John's Pizza Sebring, located in the heart of Sebring, Florida, a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction shines through. Founded on the ethos of better ingredients, better pizza, their signature sweet tomato sauce and diverse menu—featuring pizza and chicken wings—have garnered a loyal following. Customers appreciate the warm, attentive service provided by dedicated staff like manager Lexi, who go above and beyond to ensure a satisfying dining experience. Whether it’s for work parties or a cozy night in, Papa John's excels at delivering delicious pizza that brings the community together, making every meal a delightful occasion.
- 935 Sebring Square.., Sebring, FL 33870 Hotline: (863) 386-1177
Welcome to Papa Johns Pizza Sebring, a delightful culinary gem located in the heart of Sebring, Florida. Nestled at 935 Sebring Square, this establishment is not just about pizza; it's about creating a dining experience that makes every customer feel valued. For those craving great taste combined with exceptional service, Papa Johns Pizza Sebring stands as a testament to this ideal.
This franchise exudes a casual, friendly atmosphere where you can indulge in classic pizzas and enjoy a variety of chicken wings. Whether you're picking up a meal for a family gathering or ordering for a solo night in, Papa Johns Pizza Sebring aims to deliver a flavorful experience that leaves you satisfied.
- Location: 935 Sebring Square, Sebring, FL 33870
- Phone: (863) 386-1177
What sets Papa Johns apart is their commitment to quality. As food critic Domaine D. noted, each pizza boasts a unique sweetness to its sauce that complements the overall flavor. While some pizza enthusiasts may find that the sauce varies in its acidity, the base at Papa Johns tends to lean towards a subtly sweet profile, making it an appealing choice to those who enjoy a balanced palate.
One memorable highlight comes from their new New York-style pizza. While reviews noted some inconsistency in the crust's density, the overall experience of indulging in a freshly made pizza fills the belly and warms the heart. The balance of flavors offered by the sauce, along with quality toppings, makes for a rewarding meal.
Ald the pizza's quality, it's the people that truly elevate the experience at Papa Johns Pizza Sebring. Managers like Lexi demonstrate extraordinary customer service by going above and beyond to meet customer needs. Her willingness to extend delivery zones highlights a refreshing attitude in an often rigid corporate landscape. This kind of genuine care can transform a simple order into a memorable experience, and customers appreciate that touch of personalized attention.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through Sebring, you’ll find something to love at Papa Johns Pizza Sebring. Each visit promises hot, delicious pizza and the kind of warmth that comes from a devoted staff. As repeat customers like Adam E. suggest, it’s a reliable choice not just for family dinners but also for parties and events.
From delightful flavors to exceptional hospitality, Papa Johns Pizza Sebring is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. With tantalizing options for everyone, let your next pizza night begin here!

OK, first of all, I'm a food critic. I worked in executive five star dining and I know several Michelin chefs. But, every once in a while, even a guy like me wants to order a delivery pizza. At first, I was told, "no" they would not delivered to me. Because I am 1 mile outside of their radius. The young guy I spoke with recommended instead that I called Lake Placid Papa John's which is ridiculous because I'm exactly 30 seconds south of Highway 98. I think the guy was just trying to pass the buck. However, I called Lake Placid and they also said I was outside their delivery radius and that made a lot more sense to me because it would be like calling Denver, Colorado and asking for a pizza to be delivered to Florida. So what do you do? I ended up calling the Sebring location back and asked for the manager. I got Lexi on the phone. That was the manager's name. She was a young lady, but she seemed intelligent and open minded, because when I explain the circumstances to her she said, "yeah that is ridiculous" I also explain to Lexi about how much money they were losing out on because they were not willing to extend their delivery radius to the entire Sebring area. They were missing out on business from all of the people south of HCA hospital now if you think about it that's a lot of people and a lot of money to be missing out on. The radius gap between the Sebring delivery area and the Lake Placid delivery area does not touch. This means there is a huge gap where they are missing all of the Spring Lake and all of the people who live just off Highway 66. Ridiculous! I mean, if I'm a business owner and I have a pizza business, I'm gonna make sure that I cover the entire Sebring area because I'm not about to miss out on money from people because of a 1 mile extra driving radius. Lexi went on to explain to me that she was going to go ahead and allow the delivery, but she also told me that she could not guarantee that every manager would make the same choice at Papa John's. I agreed that that was likely to happen and I understood. Now the pizza: there are a lot of pizzas in this town and a lot of these guys who make them are from New York City so you're not missing out on good quality pizza here in Sebring. I will say that most of the time the sauce is very acidic no matter where you go. Papa John's sauce, which I have not had in sometime, at least 20 years has a definite sweetness. It had a good aroma, and while not punched with herbs it did satisfy the palate in a balanced way. I enjoy the sweetness that they have in their sauce whether they slow cook the onions or just added a little sweetener to the sauce. both are fine it's a matter of taste. Italians will choose one or the other. They all typically use their onions to gain this type of exposure in the flavor by a quick sear and sauté of the onions to gain a bolder aroma, or a slow cook of the onions in order to sweeten them. We ordered the new New York style pizza, and while there is not a consistency in the two pizzas we received the first one was more New York style in the crust. Well, the second one was denser and the crust endings were not equal in size, thickness, or make, but for a commercial pizza, it filled the stomach. In this review, I am complementing the manager more than anything for her ability to deliver to us. You often do not see this in commercial businesses. They are usually very stoic and black-and-white on their terms. For Lexi to think outside the box and be willing to make a personal judgment was appreciated. She was a good manager, and she is being recognized for that purpose. You hardly see this ever so kudos to you Lexi, and thank you for being a good manager!

Me and my wife go here probably once a month and we get it for work parties too, always hot and delicious! We love our Sebring Papa Johns!

After 3 power outages the staff really worked hard to fulfill my order. Very kind people and the pizza was terrific. Was a real treat! Thanks Guys!